The Most Catholic Senator?

CRISIS Magazine - e-Letter

June 3, 2004

**********************************************

Dear Friend,

We knew it was coming.

Yesterday afternoon, I received a call from a friend in Congress who
told me that Illinois Senator Richard Durbin (D-IL) had just
announced that Senator John Kerry was the "most Catholic" member of
the Senate.

Stop laughing.

Senator Durbin released an analysis of the voting record of the 24
Catholic senators -- scoring them by their adherence to the political
agenda of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB).
As I mentioned, John Kerry is ranked first, followed by Dick Durbin
himself (way to go!).

Durbin is followed by Ted Kennedy. Yes, according to Dick Durbin's
office, Ted Kennedy is the third most Catholic-voting member of the
Senate.

Pat Leahy (D-VT) and Barbara Mikulski (D-MD) round out the top 5.

(To give you some helpful perspective, the ardently Catholic Senator
Rick Santorum is 20th... just four from the bottom.)

So, what do the top five best Catholics in the Senate have in
common? Well, they're five of the most radically liberal,
pro-abortion members of congress. In fact, with the exception of
Leahy, all voted to OPPOSE the Partial-Birth Abortion ban. Not only
that, but all five voted AGAINST the Brownback Human Cloning
Prohibition Act.

But if that's all true, how on earth can anyone claim these five are
among the best Catholics on the Hill?

It was easy, actually. All Senator Durbin had to do was completely
ignore the immense difference between votes on doctrinal issues and
votes on prudential matters.

Let me explain...

In assembling his scorecard, Durbin looked at 24 issues (with a
total of 48 votes) on which the USCCB took a position. If the given
senator voted in agreement with the USCCB, he was given a point. In
the end, the points were added up, and the senators ranked.

In other words, in Senator Durbin's moral universe everything is
flat. His moral calculus becomes, well, elementary arithmetic really:
Just take all the policy recommendations of the Bishop's Conference
-- no matter how prudential or non-binding in nature -- look at the
voting record of every senator on those recommendations, and Presto!
you have your mathematical ranking.

This methodology becomes particularly outrageous when you notice
that it makes a vote for the Collins Mercury Reduction Act (which
limits the use of mercury fever thermometers) equal in weight and
importance to a vote for the Partial-Birth Abortion Ban!

Likewise, a vote for the Dorgan Joint Resolution (which rejects "the
rule submitted by the Federal Communications Commission with respect
to broadcast media ownership") is equal to a vote to ban human
cloning.

As a result, a senator who votes AGAINST the Partial-Birth Abortion
ban but for the restriction on mercury thermometers will be given the
same "Catholic" rank as the senator who votes to ban partial-birth
abortion, but against the restriction on the thermometers.

And so, Senator John Kerry -- who voted against the Partial Birth
Abortion Ban, against the Born-Alive Infant Protection Act, against
the Unborn Victims of Violence Act -- is now crowned the most
Catholic member of the Senate!

Of course, as any sensible Catholic knows, these things are not
remotely equal. Pro-life legislation touches on a doctrine of the
Church, and all faithful Catholics are bound to adhere to it. The
restriction on thermometers, on the other hand, is a mere prudential
judgment of the USCCB; they believe it to be a matter of public
health, but faithful Catholics are free to disagree.

By confounding prudential and doctrinal matters, Senator Durbin has
made a desperate attempt to provide cover for all the pro-abortion
"Catholics" in the Senate (both Democrats and Republicans).

The question now is whether or not the Bishops Conference will allow
this mockery of Catholic social teaching to pass through the media
without comment or clarification. Will it be up to individual
bishops, once again, to deal with the propaganda of the pro-abortion
"Catholic" crowd in Congress?

The USCCB actually has a unique opportunity to take a stand here...


Very soon, the conference will be issuing its questionnaire to the
presidential candidates. You may recall that in the 2000 election,
there was a dustup when the Catholic News Service allowed Al Gore to
describe himself as "pro-life" without any editorial comment or
correction. This year, the content of the Conference questionnaire
will be vital in determining what the Conference considers important
to learn from the presidential candidates.

Will the questionnaire follow the Durbin model of a flat moral
universe where issues like the level of the minimum wage count the
same as a vote on the protection of innocent life? Or will the
questionnaire be weighted to reveal the candidates' views on matters
that actually bind the Catholic's conscience?

As soon as it's made public, I'll let you know.

Talk to you soon,

Deal


******* WHAT REALLY CAUSED THE CRISIS IN THE CHURCH? *******

Sex abuse scandals... irreverent liturgies... homosexuality in the
seminaries... liberal theology preached from the pulpit...

You know all about the crisis in the Church. But you've never heard
the full story. When did the collapse in the Church occur... and what
REALLY caused it?

Fr. Benedict Groeschel knows. He was there when it happened... 10
years BEFORE Vatican II.

What he saw will surprise you.

Click here to learn more:

http://www.crisismagazine.com/products.htm

[Cut and paste into your browser if the link isn't active]

**************************************************************

To subscribe to the FREE CRISIS Magazine e-Letter, and get the
latest
news, views, and responses to current issues, send an e-mail to
e-letter@crisismagazine.com and write "SUBSCRIBE" in the subject
line.

**************************************************************

To learn more about CRISIS Magazine, visit
http://www.crisismagazine.com/subscribe.htm

**************************************************************

If you no longer wish to receive the CRISIS e-Letter, please send an

e-mail to mail@crisismagazine.com and write "CANCEL" in the subject

line.

**************************************************************

To change your e-mail address, please send an e-mail to
mail@crisismagazine.com with "ADDRESS CHANGE" in the subject line.
Please make sure to tell us your old and new e-mail addresses, so we
can
make the change.

**************************************************************

Please forward this letter to anyone you think might benefit from
it.