Dear Colleague:
Hong Kong's new interim chief executive wants his fellow citizens to have
more children, but most in China's gateway city have other ideas. Can he
persuade them to do so?
Steven W. Mosher
President
PRI Weekly Briefing
11 March 2005
Vol. 7 / No. 10
Pro-Natal Official Takes Over in Hong Kong
By Joseph A. D'Agostino
The month after he urged Hong Kong couples to have more children, Sir
Donald Tsang became acting chief executive of Hong Kong following the
retirement of Tung Chee-hwa. Formerly chief secretary for administration,
Tsang will govern Hong Kong, a semi-autonomous region subordinated to
mainland China, on a day-to-day basis until a committee controlled by
China's Communist government chooses a permanent replacement for Tung.
Tsang, a Catholic with two sons, could easily be its choice.
In a major departure from the Communist Chinese government line, which
enforces a one-child policy on mainland Chinese, Tsang urged Hong Kong
couples to have three children apiece in order to counteract falling
birthrates and an aging population. He said on a Radio Television Hong
Kong program last month, "Hong Kong has one of the lowest total fertility
rates in the world and we need to think about how to resolve the problems
discouraging people from having children. . . . I think each couple needs
to give birth to at least two children to reach the population replacement
level. Three will be the best."
Two children are often considered the maximum throughout East Asia, and
large numbers of couples will not consider having more than one. Tsang's
recommendation runs counter not only to Chinese government policy, but to
popular sentiment in this increasingly wealthy part of the world. Still,
this did not stop him from being named interim chief executive. Perhaps
even China's anti-family Communist leadership recognizes that Hong Kong is
in dire straits. In the meantime, the nearby sovereign city-state of
Singapore has implemented a host of financial incentives to persuade its
low-fertility population to have more children.
Hong Kong, with a population of 7 million, has a fertility rate of .94
children per woman, far below the 2.1 children per woman required to
maintain an even population level. Hong Kong's rate is even below those
of Italy and Spain, whose people are fast committing national suicide with
fertility rates slightly above 1.
It's interesting to note the success of population control efforts
everywhere in the world, regardless of cultural or economic differences.
Mainland China is poor, but its fertility rate is low after decades of
coercion by the government, assisted by the United Nations. Hong Kong and
Singapore are rich, but they too have low fertility rates because of
urbanization, modernization, and a female population now in the workforce.
Hong Kong had been partially making up its lack of fecundity with
immigration from the mainland, but that's no longer working. The number
of mainland Chinese seeking to move to Hong Kong has been dropping in the
past few years. In just one year, from 2003 to 2004, the number seeking
one-way permits to move dropped from 53,000 to 34,000. Experts predict
that as economic life continues to improve on the mainland, there will be
fewer and fewer people who wish to move to Hong Kong, where the cost of
living is among the highest in the world. Hong Kong is so expensive that
tiny apartments rent for thousands of dollars U.S. a month. Hong Kong is
also somewhat insular, with its own specific English- and
Cantonese-speaking culture and a certain distaste for their poor country
cousins across the border.
At the same time, young men are fleeing Hong Kong in droves. In the
meantime, women are moving into Hong Kong to be maids or to marry
wealthier Hong Kong men, leading to a growing gender imbalance that also
bodes ill for future fertility.
Hong Kong's government expects the proportion of the population 65 and
over to increase to 27% in 2033 from 11.7% in 2003. The median age will
jump to 49 from 38. The coming dearth of working-age people and surfeit
of retirees means Hong Kong faces the same demographic time bomb as the
rest of the developed world. Tsang may well be asking himself: Who will
perform the labor in the future? Who will pay the taxes to support
retirees' government benefits?
Judging from a poll and Hong Kong news reports, Tsang's goal will be hard
to implement. In a poll conducted after Tsang made his comments, 90% of
Hong Kong parents surveyed said that having three children was next to
impossible. "It was a call greeted with almost universal disdain,"
reported the Hong Kong Standard on March 4. "More than 95% of 624 mothers
interviewed rejected Tsang's call, saying government benefits are not
sufficient to support an extra child. Nearly 90% said they will not have
more than two children. Financial considerations, especially the high
cost of education, is the major concern for couples planning to have
children, according to the survey." Currently, parents receive a
HK$30,000 (US$3,850) tax allowance per child, but education, especially in
the large numbers of private schools, is expensive.
Singapore is well ahead of Hong Kong in offering financial incentives for
child-bearing. "Singapore, also beset by a seriously slowing birth rate,
offers a wide range of benefits to parents, such as grants for child
savings accounts ranging from HK$28,500 and HK$57,000, and even monthly
subsidies of about HK$1,900 for babysitting," noted the Standard. "The
first two babies each receive HK$15,000 grants, while the third and fourth
receive HK$28,500."
The absorption of women out of the home and into workplaces in modern
economies and government promises to provide support in old age have made
children dispensable economic liabilities in the eyes of most. Mothers
don't have time for kids anymore. "The responsibilities of raising a
family dilute the earning power of working mothers, discouraging them from
having more children," reported the Standard on March 7. "That is the
view of 49-year-old mother Tam Fung-hing, who noted the difficulty of
having a full-time job as a clerk for 18 years while bringing up two
children, now teenagers." She's between a rock and a hard place, telling
the newspaper, "I cannot quit my job because I need money to raise the
children."
Let's pray Donald Tsang can save Hong Kong from demographic
self-destruction.
Joseph A. D'Agostino is Vice President for Communications at PRI.
_________
PRI
P.O. Box 1559
Front Royal, VA 22630
USA
Phone: (540) 622-5240 Fax: (540) 622-2728
Email: jad@pop.org
Media Contact: Joseph A. D'Agostino
(540) 622-5240, ext. 204
_________
© 2005 Population Research Institute. Permission to reprint granted.
Redistribute widely. Credit required.
_________
If you would like to make a tax-deductible donation to PRI, please go to
https://pop.org/donate.cfm. All
donations (of any size) are welcomed and
appreciated.
_________
To subscribe to the Weekly Briefing, send an email to:
JOIN-PRI@Pluto.Sparklist.com
or email pri@pop.org and say "Add me to your
Weekly Briefing."
__________
The Population Research Institute is dedicated to ending human rights
abuses committed in the name of "family planning," and to ending
counter-productive social and economic paradigms premised on the myth of
"overpopulation."