Dear Colleague:

An inversion has occurred: Husbands and fathers who murder their wives and
daughters instead of protecting them are now celebrated.  Witness the
success of Clint Eastwood's Million-Dollar Baby and the near-success of
Michael Schiavo's effort to kill his wife, Terri.

Steven W. Mosher
President

PRI Weekly Briefing
4 March 2005
Vol. 7 / No. 9

A Million Dollars for Messrs. Eastwood and Schiavo
By Joseph A. D'Agostino
 
Euthanasia is enjoying its greatest renaissance in the Western world since
Nazi Germany.  Together with so many other social ideas first popularized
in modern times by Nazis and Communists from abortion to easy divorce,
euthanasia's time may have come.  Doctors in the Netherlands are
euthanizing disabled infants even without parental consent, and Britain's
Labour government may be about to legalize widespread euthanasia there.
Our own state of Oregon has a physician-assisted suicide law.  Hollywood's
elite, ever on the cutting edge of evil, gave its implicit imprimatur to
exterminating the unfit to live by granting Academy Awards the other day
to two movies that feature euthanasia, Million Dollar Baby and The Sea
Inside.

The latter, which won the Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film, is a
Spanish movie with small impact and circulation outside of arty circles.
It is also clear to prospective filmgoers what it is about: A man's effort
to kill himself legally.  PG-13-rated Million Dollar Baby, which won Best
Picture, is a major Hollywood release that has grossed $65 million
already, and no doubt many people, including minors, went to see it with
no idea that the film promoted the "mercy" killing of disabled people.
Director Clint Eastwood won Best Director.

The film revolves around the story of Maggie (played by Hillary Swank, who
won Best Actress), a female boxer who achieves success with the help of
coach and surrogate father Frankie (played by Eastwood), but then is
gravely injured in a boxing match.  I have not seen the movie and do not
intend to since I do not enjoy watching women being beaten-even by other
women.  Therefore, I will not attempt to critique the movie artistically
but only discuss undisputed plot points.

"First, Maggie becomes a ventilator-dependent quadriplegic, after once
living a life of utter physicality.  That would be difficult to adjust to
even under ideal circumstances," wrote Wesley J. Smith in the Weekly
Standard.  "But Maggie's life as a disabled woman is anything but ideal.
Despite supposedly receiving the best of care she soon develops bed sores
so serious that one of her legs is amputated. . . . Third, her venal and
uncaring family refuses to visit, and when they do, she is pressured into
signing over control of her assets.  Fourthly, after trying to kill
herself in a terribly painful way, she is force-sedated to prevent further
suicide attempts.  Frankie is in anguish over his friend's plight and
concludes that he is actually killing Maggie by letting her live.  So, in
his love for her, he overcomes his Catholic guilt and murders Maggie by
removing the respirator and injecting her with an overdose of adrenalin."

Hollywood has long loved to portray euthanasia, and so have other film
industries over time.  "Indeed, in the past movies were made as explicit
propaganda to promote the legalization and legitimacy of active
euthanasia," Smith wrote.  "The most notorious of these is the 1939 German
movie I Accuse (Ich Klage An), a film that, with Goebbles's blessing, both
promoted voluntary euthanasia as well as the propriety of killing disabled
infants-to blockbuster success at the box office.  It is striking and
disturbing how similar the plotline of Million Dollar Baby is to the
voluntary euthanasia story in I Accuse."  The heroines in both movies ask
their "their primary male companions (the husband in I Accuse and
surrogate father in Million Dollar Baby) to put them out of their misery,"
said Smith, a lawyer for the International Task Force on Euthanasia and
Assisted Suicide.

Another primary male companion is out to eliminate a woman from the world
but, unfortunately, these two people are real.  And the woman never asked
to be eliminated.  Michael Schiavo has spent years trying to kill his
severely disabled wife, Terri.  Her end may finally have come, and if it
does, it will set a precedent that will eviscerate the rights of the
disabled in this country.  Since Terri lives in Florida, the precedent
will be especially ominous for the large number of retirees who live
there.

"Judge Greer has ruled that she is to be executed March 18," said Eleanor
Drechsel, an activist who assists Terri's parents, Robert and Mary
Schindler, in trying to save Terri's life.  The case is an especially
disturbing one because, among other reasons:

1. Terri never said or signed anything that said she would want to be
killed if she ever became disabled.
2. Terri is not on life support.  She receives food from a tube connected
at mealtimes, but otherwise her essential functions perform unaided.
3. Terri is conscious.  She responds to stimuli, watches people walk
around her room, and sometimes even responds to commands.  She is not in a
vegetative state.
4. The man making decisions for her, her husband Michael, has already
abandoned her.  He lives with his girlfriend-he has called her his
"fiancé"-and the two children he has had by her.
5. Efforts to rehabilitate Terri and teach her how to eat and speak ceased
in 1991, the year after she was injured, even though some medical experts
say it is possible such efforts could succeed.
6. Terri's parents want to care for her, but Michael will not allow it or
grant a civil divorce.
7. Terri was a practicing Catholic before she became disabled and as such
most likely opposes euthanasia.
8. Over a million dollars awarded in a malpractice suit for Terri's
rehabilitation has instead gone to Michael's attorneys' fees and other
expenses.  Michael has consistently blocked rehabilitative efforts.  If
Terri had died earlier, Michael would have inherited a large sum of money,
but now only $50,000 remains as far as anyone can tell publicly.
9. No one knows how Terri received her injuries but a pathologist reported
that she had "a history of trauma."  There is no proof that Michael is
responsible.
10. The plan is to murder Terri through starvation by denying her food.
It is illegal to kill animals this way in Florida because it is so cruel.

Court after court decision has come down on the side of death.  The wishes
of Florida's elected legislators and governor have been ignored.  Terri's
parents are still making last-ditch legal efforts to save their daughter,
and the Florida Department of Children and Families has finally begun an
investigation into whether Terri suffered abuse.  But Judge George Greer
won't move the March 18 execution date.  Terri's supporters plan a vigil
outside the Woodside Hospice in Pinellas Park, Fla. for March 12.  For
more information, go to www.terrisfight.org.

We live in an age when feminists are quick to tar all men as violent, in
which judges often accept unsubstantiated accusations of domestic violence
against men as fact, and in which men in general are portrayed as
oppressors of women.  But then when some agenda more important is at
stake, such considerations are put aside.  It happened in the O.J. Simpson
case.  It's happening now in the Schiavo case.  In the former, racial
politics was more important than murder.  In the latter, murder of the
unfit to live through euthanasia is more important than a woman's right to
life.

Has Michael Schiavo fulfilled his duty as a husband?  Did Clint Eastwood's
character perform his role as surrogate father?  Is Clint Eastwood's
vision of disabled people true to life?  "While it is true that many
people who become quadriplegic later in life become very depressed and
suicidal-like Maggie in the movie-studies show that such existential
despair is not usually permanent," Smith wrote.  "Indeed, one medical
report published several years ago found that the level of depression in
people disabled later in life to be no different five years post-injury
than that found among the able bodied."  Perhaps Eastwood's character
should have gotten his surrogate daughter through her difficult period.
Isn't that what a good father would do?  Couldn't the lives of Stephen
Hawking and Christopher Reeves have served as models for Eastwood in the
making of this film?  Both refused to simply lie down and die.

As for Mr. Schiavo, we remind him of the words of St. John Chrysostom.  In
a commentary on Ephesians, after discussing St. Paul's injunction that
wives must obey their spouses, he admonished husbands, "Thou hast seen the
measure of obedience, hear also the measure of love.  Wouldest thou have
thy wife obedient unto thee, as the Church is to Christ?  Take then
thyself the same provident care for her, as Christ takes for the Church.
Even if it shall be needful for thee to give thy life for her, and to be
cut into pieces ten thousand times, and to endure and undergo any
suffering whatever, refuse it not.  Though thou shouldest undergo all
this, yet wilt thou not, no, not even then, have done anything like
Christ."

It's bad enough when a man kills another man, especially when he's
vulnerable.  A few decades ago, a man deliberately killing a suffering
woman would not have been celebrated in life or in fiction.  Except in
Nazi Germany.


Joseph A. D'Agostino is Vice President for Communications at PRI.

 
_________
PRI
P.O. Box 1559
Front Royal, VA 22630
USA

Phone: (540) 622-5240 Fax: (540) 622-2728
Email: jad@pop.org
Media Contact: Joseph A. D'Agostino
(540) 622-5240, ext. 204
_________
© 2005 Population Research Institute. Permission to reprint granted.
Redistribute widely. Credit required.
_________
If you would like to make a tax-deductible donation to PRI, please go to
https://pop.org/donate.cfm. All donations (of any size) are welcomed and
appreciated.
_________
To subscribe to the Weekly Briefing, send an email to:
JOIN-PRI@Pluto.Sparklist.com or email pri@pop.org and say "Add me to your
Weekly Briefing."
__________
The Population Research Institute is dedicated to ending human rights
abuses committed in the name of "family planning," and to ending
counter-productive social and economic paradigms premised on the myth of
"overpopulation."